Message |
Details |
If both are valid, both variants should be listed in my opinion.
In this case, the biggest question is whether an on set vfx supervisor is a valid credit and whether this is a credit we are really looking for. | Posted: Topic Replies: 19, Topic Views: 1556 |
 |
What's the common name for Art Director Tom/Thomas Whitehead
Tom Whitehead 5 Confirmed Dolittle confirmed by Gamemaster Jurassic World: Dominion confirmed by Gamemaster Kingsman: The Secret Service confirmed by Gamemaster The Marvels confirmed by Gamemaster The Mummy (2017) confirmed by Gamemaster
Thomas Whitehead 3 Confirmed The Huntsman: Winter's War confirmed by Gamemaster Solo: A Star Wars Story confirmed by Gamemaster Vampire Academy confirmed by Gamemaster
Unconfirmed -Don Quixote --> However since this is an acting credit I think this is a different person, but please let me know.
The common name is Tom Whitehead
Current CLT Results: Tom Whitehead 15 titles (166 profiles) Thomas Whitehead 12 titles (161 profiles)
Notice that there is a Tom Whitehaed with 3 titles (62 profiles) in the database as well. All 62 credits are invalid!
If I've missed a title or made a mistake please let me know. | Posted: Topic Replies: 0, Topic Views: 200 |
 |
Quoting mitchg:
Quote: Quoting CubbyUps:
Quote: Stephen Bishop (1951) Family Guy Twilight Zone: The Movie Laverne & Shirley The Blues Brothers Animal House http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0084196/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stephen_Bishop_(musician) http://www.bluesbrotherscentral.com/profiles/stephen-bishop/
Stephen Bishop CSI: Miami Lost Brothers & Sisters The Rundown http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1212071/
Approved May 6,2010
Found the BY for the other Stephen Bishop. BY = 1971 >> Wikipedia
1971 BY Contributed - Status Approved on January 9, 2014
Looks like the birth year for the second Stephen Bishop is 1970 Both the wikipedia and IMDB says it's 1970. | Posted: Topic Replies: 5798, Topic Views: 398827 |
 |
Quoting CubbyUps:
Quote: Peter Bishop
Actor BY=1967 http://www.iafd.com/person.rme/perfid=peterbishop/gender=m/peter-bishop.htm
Actor BY=? https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1521089/
Writer BY=? https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1684901/
Actor BY=? https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0084166/
The birth year for the writer is 1930
Writer BY=1930 https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1684901/ https://www.mirrorpensioners.co.uk/obituary/peter-bishop/ | Posted: Topic Replies: 5798, Topic Views: 398827 |
 |
Quoting emmeli:
Quote: Quoting ninso4:
Quote: Elizabeth Bennett
Actress NCIS, Castle BY= 1978 http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0071742/
Actress Mr.Bean BY=? http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0071739/
Elizabeth Bennett (1944) Mr.Bean, Largo Winch http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0071739/
1944 BY contributed
Status: Approved Jul 17 2014
It looks like it's a matter of time before the birth year for Elizabeth Bennett (1978) is not needed anymore. However I found a third Elizabeth Bennett, so the birth year for Elizabeth Bennett (1944) is still needed when the common name for Elizabeth Bennett (1978) flips.
Elizabeth Bennett (??) Director/Writer: Come Outside with Auntie Mabel and Pippin: Animals, Come Outside with Auntie Mabel and Pippin: Food -https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1002518 | Posted: Topic Replies: 5798, Topic Views: 398827 |
 |
Are you sure about Liberty Heights? When I looked it up it was Elizabeth Ann Bennett. See Youtube
Liberty Heights --> Elizabeth Ann Bennett as Mary Matchmaker Santa --> Elizabeth Ann Bennett as Blaire
Helter Skelter --> Elizabeth Bennett as "Gibby" Abigail Folger Kung Fu Panda: Secrets of the Furious Five --> Elizabeth Bennett as Ant & Bunny Soul's Midnight --> Elizabeth Bennett as Alicia
I think these are the missing titles from CLT
Elizabeth Bennett -CSI: NY: The Complete Second Season (2.1) -Military Intelligence and You! -NCIS: Naval Criminal Investigative Service: Season 3 (3.9) -Point Pleasant: The Complete Series (1.5, 1.9, 1.10, 1.11, 1.12, 1.13)
Elizabeth Ann Bennett -CSI: Miami: Season 7 (7.14) -Grey's Anatomy: Complete Eleventh Season (11.22, 11.23) -The Last Ship - The Complete Second Season (2.10)
Probably some one else but not 100% sure, but I don't think a 7 year old girl plays a Woman Reporter  -Lace II (1985)
It looks like's Elizabeth Bennett will be the common name, but with the newest credits all for Elizabeth Ann Bennett it will be a matter of time this will flip. | Posted: Topic Replies: 3, Topic Views: 1879 |
 |
Quoting Devion27:
Quote: Andy Berman 1968
Psych, Rocket Power, Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman, etc
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0075724/?ref_=ttfc_fc_wr21#producer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andy_Berman
Andy Berman
Fighting With my Family
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm11663445/?ref_=ttfc_fc_cr3
Submitting Andy Berman 1968
All the credits in the database for Andy Berman are for the same person. So the birth year is not needed anymore.
Also the IMDB link for Andy Berman without a birth year is redirected to the IMDB link for Andy Berman (1968). | Posted: Topic Replies: 280, Topic Views: 77678 |
 |
New Year's Evil --> Jonathan Stein Basic Training --> Jonathan Stein
And with these two titles Jonathan Stein is the common name with 17 titles. | Posted: Topic Replies: 58, Topic Views: 16819 |
 |
Quoting Devion27:
Quote: adding Chris Barnes 1972
Captain Planet, The Brady Bunch Movie, The Little Mermaid, etc
https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0055549/?ref_=ttfc_fc_cl_t57
Why? His common name is Christopher Daniel Barnes | Posted: Topic Replies: 5798, Topic Views: 398827 |
 |
80 for Brady --> David De Leon as Key Make-Up Artist to Ms. Fonda Book Club: The Next Chapter --> David De Leon as Make-up Artist Ms. Fonda
Book Club --> David DeLeon as Makeup Artist to Ms. Fonda Moving On --> David DeLeon as Makeup Artist for Jane Fonda
Still a tie.... | Posted: Topic Replies: 11, Topic Views: 8122 |
 |
New Variant: Gerarld Staddon
Star Wars: Episode VI - Return of the Jedi (1983) --> Gerarld Staddon as Ewoks | Posted: Topic Replies: 6, Topic Views: 2684 |
 |
Quoting paulb_99:
Quote: Tried adding BY for the actor with a profile update for Bridge at Remagen but this lead to numerous error pages, is this a known issue?
Since the website moved to another server months ago it's not possible to add new birth years anymore. And it doesn't look like it will be solved. | Posted: Topic Replies: 5798, Topic Views: 398827 |
 |
I've checked my database and I still have all three variants in my database. Although the previous change was subtle, I can still remember that this was an issue then and that I had no votes on a number of contributions. Given the reactions in this topic, I don't expect this to happen again 
It would have been best if the symbols themselves could be added as details, but that will never happen, because even simple errors after the server migration are not fixed.
I was initially curious whether similar situations had already occurred in other localities and how this was handled. Unfortunately, no one has been able to clarify this so far.
I can live with both options as long as it is done by everyone. So either the same description for the symbol everywhere or the 3 different descriptions based on the release date. I think I have a slight preference for keeping it at 1 description because that is the clearest. That does mean that I have to adjust a few hundred profiles and if the description changes again, I would have to do this again. For now I'm waiting for the screeners' verdict on whether they approve this for old profiles or not.
As I said, I would prefer to see that you could choose symbols, because apart from the 3 variants for this one symbol I also see different ways of writing it. In particular (copied) Belgian profiles often use capitalized versions such as "Roken, Alcohol en Drugs" of "Grof Taalgebruik". It would be nice if that was also limited to capitalizing the first letter and only the first rating detail. | Posted: Topic Replies: 11, Topic Views: 5391 |
 |
I'm Looking for the common name for this Editor. If I have missed a title or another variant please let me know.
Craig P. Herring 10 Confirmed Are We Done Yet? confirmed by Gamemaster Bedazzled confirmed by Gamemaster Dr. Dolittle 2 confirmed by Gamemaster Good Boy! confirmed by Gamemaster Scary Movie 4 confirmed by Gamemaster Sleepover confirmed by Gamemaster Superhero Movie confirmed by Gamemaster Tuxedo, The confirmed by Gamemaster Year One confirmed by Gamemaster
Craig Herring 9 Confirmed Middle School: The Worst Years of My Life confirmed by Gamemaster Movie 43 confirmed by Gamemaster Multiplicity confirmed by Gamemaster My Big Fat Greek Wedding 3 confirmed by TIM Rebound confirmed by Gamemaster Stuart Saves His Family confirmed by Gamemaster Sundown confirmed by Gamemaster Tooken confirmed by Gamemaster War With Grandpa confirmed by Gamemaster
The common name is Craig P. Herring
Current CLT Status Craig P. Herring 13 titles (247 profiles) Craig Herring 11 titles (81 profiles) | Posted: Topic Replies: 2, Topic Views: 4463 |
 |
I don't know if this has happened in other countries/ratingsystems.
For the second time, the description of a rating detail (symbol) has been changed. Should the description for all profiles where this symbol is used be updated now, or only the profiles from the date when the change took place? | Posted: Topic Replies: 11, Topic Views: 5391 |
 |
I think I've requested this two years ago, but like other changes nothing is done with this. | Posted: Topic Replies: 11, Topic Views: 5391 |
 |
I think most of the Dutch profiles are not that bad. The profiles that are copied from crappy Belgian profiles and haven't been updated properly are probably the biggest problem. | Posted: Topic Replies: 11, Topic Views: 5391 |
 |
Drugs- en/of alcoholmisbruik was used till November 2015 Drugs- en/of alcoholgebruik was used till April 2022 So "Roken, alcohol en drugs" is already used from April 2022
And a little sidenote nounces like "alcoholgebruik" should be written lowercase according the Dutch capitalization rules. | Posted: Topic Replies: 11, Topic Views: 5391 |
 |
Wanted Man --> Roger Cross as Hernandez | Posted: Topic Replies: 73, Topic Views: 18255 |
 |
I think I'm running out of negative votes today.....
I don't think I've seen it as bad as it is today. Fortunately, it's still limited to this subforum, but I wonder how long that will last.
I have no idea how many serious new users still sign up, but it might be a good idea to close the registration and take a closer look at the registration procedure. | Posted: Topic Replies: 5, Topic Views: 3100 |
 |
I'm Looking for the common name for this Sound guy. If I have missed a title or another variant please let me know.
Bjørn Ole Schroeder 8 Confirmed Allied confirmed by Gamemaster Big Eyes confirmed by Gamemaster Fantastic Fear of Everything, A confirmed by Gamemaster Mary, Mother of Jesus confirmed by Gamemaster Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar Children confirmed by Gamemaster Only the Brave confirmed by Gamemaster Roald Dahl's The Witches confirmed by Gamemaster Walk, The confirmed by Gamemaster
Bjorn Schroeder 3 Confirmed Arabian Nights confirmed by Gamemaster Breaking the Bank confirmed by T!M Vivo confirmed by Gamemaster
Bjørn Schroeder 2 Confirmed Kajillionaire confirmed by Gamemaster Top Gun: Maverick confirmed by LKanne
Bjorn Ole Schroeder 2 Confirmed Prince & the Pauper, The confirmed by Gamemaster Sorted confirmed by Gamemaster
Bjørn O. Schroeder 1 Confirmed Welcome to Marwen confirmed by Gamemaster
Bjorn Shroeder 1 Confirmed Breaking the Bank confirmed by T!M
Invalid x-Event Horizon --> Bjorn Schroeder as Assistant Editor x-Ever After: A Cinderella Story --> Bjorn Ole Schroeder as First Assistant Sound Editor x-Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban --> Bjørn Ole Schroeder as Sound Effects Editor x-Lost Empire, The --> Bjorn Schroeder as ADR Editor x-Tarzan and the Lost City --> Bjørn O. Schroeder as Dialogue and Music Editor
Current CLT Status Bjørn Ole Schroeder 9 titles (156 profiles) Bjorn Schroeder 3 titles (12 profiles) Bjørn Schroeder 4 titles (55 profiles) Bjorn Ole Schroeder 12 titles (54 profiles) Bjørn O. Schroeder 1 titles (17 profiles) Bjorn Shroeder 3 titles (4 profiles)
The common name is Bjørn Ole Schroeder | Posted: Topic Replies: 3, Topic Views: 6065 |
 |
Quoting mreeder50:
Quote: Escape From L.A.: Film Editor ... EDWARD A. WARSCHILKA
Rambo III: Not Listed Invalid
There are 3 other editors in the opening credits, but in the post production section in the end credits he's listed.
However IMDB list the father as Editor and not the son, so we have to look at that as well if we decided to list him. | Posted: Topic Replies: 11, Topic Views: 6393 |
 |
Deadfall --> Jean-François "Jafaz" Ferland as Visual Effects Supervisor
La chute de l'empire américain --> Jean-François Ferland as Conception et supervision effets visuels | Posted: Topic Replies: 19, Topic Views: 10498 |
 |
Land of Bad --> Phill Eagles as Costime Designer
With this title we have a tie, but with the larger number of profiles Phil is, in my opinion, still the common name.
However on IMDB he's listed as another Phill Eagles, but I think it's the same person. If not please let all of us know. | Posted: Topic Replies: 13, Topic Views: 18054 |
 |
Quoting GSyren:
Quote: My understanding is that extras are non-speaking background performers, while additional cast are actors with spoken dialog in minor roles. If that is correct, then they are not comparable. Personally I wouldn't include them, but the rules are not clear on that point, I think. However it's just a list without roles, I think it's safe to say they're indeed non speaking background performers like people sitting in restaurants, pedestrians etc.
I didn't want to influence the topic, but pesonally I agree what you say and I don't think I would have include them either. The majority, on the other hand, wants to include them, so I think I respect that. | Posted: Topic Replies: 6, Topic Views: 3522 |