What did you put in your notes? Where did you get the info from?

Per Rules you must take the info from the actual DVD credits. Not a place like IMDB or similar. You have to actually put the disc in the machine and run the opening/end credits. I never seen the director not credited in either the opening or end credits. Especially on something as big as Disney.

Right... Thank You dee1959jay... that is something I should have mentioned. If there is crew not credited on the film... we can not add them at this time per Rules... as there is no way to mark them as uncredited.

Yeah sure... he said in that case. But there is nothing said here in the OP to make you think it is even anything like that case. How often have you seen a legitimate release of a Disney Flick with no crew credits what so ever?

I guess that is all in how you read Ken's statement as he said...

Quote:
I see no problem listing the cast (as uncredited) and crew from the official site in this case.

See the portion that I put in bold. Read that literally as it is written he said in that case. Not in cases such as that... so reading it literally he would have to say yes or no on a case by case basis. Not decide whether it is a similar case or not and do accordingly.

Thank you for your time and answers.
Okay, I noted that I should get my infos from opening or ending credits. BUT what about when the info is not on the DVD? You take a 1937 movie for example, production year is NOT there, if you're interested, you DO have to get the info somewhere...
I thought that DVD profiler would accept informations MISSING from the Data base and that it would validate the information after "x" number of votes. 
Personally, I contributed to foreign editions of DVDs (adding Directors) that are ALREADY in DVD Profiler for U.S. editions so I still find my contributions should have been added in some ways.
I understand why they were declined but if I, or other people, contribute the right informations, I think they should be checked and added, iIt would be better for everybody :-D

It can be confusing at times. The more you contribute the easier it gets so don't get discouraged.

The best and most accurate source for the data is, of course, the DVD itself. So, get as much information as you can from the DVD.

If you only enter this data, and document that this is where you got the information, your contribution should be accepted every time.

It is only when you get into data that is NOT available on the DVD or its cover that problems arise. You can contribute this data but the correct way to do it can get confusing.

Many things are not found on the DVD such as SRP, CoO, Production Years, etc. Sometimes films list the actor's name but not roles.

Excluding Crew, which has been touched on by others, the data must be found in other places.

In those cases you need to familiarize yourself with

Quoting dee1959jay:

Quote:
Contribution Rules.

as well as Collected Statements from Invelos on contribution discussions found here: http://invelos.com/Forums.aspx?task=viewtopic&topicID=430575.

It is important to remember that if you take information from an outside source (such as IMDb, TCM.com, amazon.com etc.) that you confirm that data using multiple sources.

There are reasons for this - including legal ones - that this is required. It also helps to insure the data is accurate if multiple sources confirm the information.

If you still have questions, or are unsure of something, you can always come to the forums and ask.

I think these posts give you a guideline of how to get your contributions accepted. It really isn't that difficult once you get used to it.

Good luck!