Are they the only costume / wardrobe credits?

Might these credits be considered equivalent to "Wardrobe Supervisor", which is contributable?

---------------

Quoting scotthm:

Quote:
Are they the only costume / wardrobe credits?

Sometimes they are, sometimes they're not. Why would that matter? The rules on the "Costume Designer" credit certainly don't make that distinction.

Quote:
Might these credits be considered equivalent to "Wardrobe Supervisor", which is contributable?

Just to illustrate where this leads: if there are no "Sound Editors" credited, but there were "Sound Effects Editors", should those be entered instead? Because the same approach could be applied to that: Might these credits be considered equivalent to "Sound Editor", which is contributable? Is that what we want? If the jobs in the crew credits table don't appear in the film credits, we just enter the next best thing, whatever looks close enough? That sounds like a very slippery slope...

For everybody who has no acces to the rules forum, this was the outcome of a longer thread:
Quoting AiAustria:

Quote:
Quoting antolod:

Quote:
How about this?

Quote:
Costume Designer:
Costume Designer
Costumes Designed by
Costumes by
Costumes Created by
Wardrobe Designer
Wardrobe Created by
Gowns/Costumes/Clothes/Wardrobe/Uniforms for [Cast Name/Group] (Designed) by

If no Costume Designer credit:
Gowns by
Wardrobe by
Costume Supervisor
Wardrobe Supervisor

Note: if a Designer is credited, do not credit Supervisors.

Incorrect Roles:
(Any) Provided by, Courtesy of, or Company names.
Wardrobe Mistress
Wardrobe Master
Costumer

I think, this is a good proposal to get the creative people and leave out the costumers and taylors.

Can we forward this proposal to the Support team?

... which was forwarded to the support.

Wardrobe Mistress/Master is generally a credit for the person in charge of keeping up with the costumes, making sure they're cleaned/pressed/together/ready for the production.  This is not a design credit.

We must consider that going forward, Invelos is not going to be involved at all.  In anything; rules related or not.  There are not very many regular contributors any longer, so if we have come to a consensus, my opinion is we should go by that, and run the rules as a community rather than waiting for guidance from above that is never going to come.  (Much like where I work, in 16 years I've never met the owner of our shop, we workers simply run the place as we see fit.  As long as he gets his money, Dan doesn't care what we do.)

Quoting scotthm:

Quote:

I'm personally more concerned about profiles being modified by people who don't have the discs than I am about the difference between "Wardrobe Supervisor" and "Wardrobe Master".

---------------

by modified do you mean correcting cast/crew credits, production year original titles. Usually on profiles that haven't been touched since the birth of Invelos?