The simple answer is if you think Sound Engineer is an equivalent role for the Sound credit, then solicit Ken to add it to the credit table.

Until then it doesn't matter how "pedantic" it may seem to you.

Hal and Tim are both correct. And the BEST answer remains an OPEN Crew listing, then ALL of this will end and there will be no more shoehorning.

Skip

Quoting T!M:

Quote:
Or just use common sense in combination with the best feature of all: locks! 

Well, that's what I do now anyway.  If I didn't, a healthy chunk of my golden-age cinema collection would be comprised of silent films with no music. 

Enry:

This was discussed and ruled out as it would make the data virtually meaningless, and i would agree with that original decision and assessment. What is really neeeded is some form of Open Credits where we aren't trying to define things and argue about things, you simply enter the data as you see it. Perhaps retaining the Categories but have the data entered in Open form, although i fear even that would bring it's own share of arguments, what goes into Writing or Sound etc, etc. The best answer is just Open Credits but while that would reduce discussion and argument, it woould bring its own issues to the table.

Skip

I know, Pete, but even that would be preferable to this crap.

Skip

Ahh! Open credits.  Finally i could capture the crew i care about most.  Craft Services (but not Honey Wagons).  And Wranglers of Insects and Birds (but not Mammals).  Now we're cookin'